Error adding a drive... please help!

[Titan Alpha]

I formatted my machine and reinstalled windows. After reinstalling everything the pool drive showed up as it should and my pool was where it was before. Problem is I have a 500gb SSD that's perfectly healthy from another machine but i cant add it to the pool. If its unformatted with no partition, it shows up in the list. When I add it I get this error. If i try to create a simple partition and format it it works fine in windows, but Stablebit doesn't see it in the list to add! Any help is appreciated!

[Shane]

When you format it manually, does it show up as only having one volume in Windows Disk Management, with all four of the following: Simple, Basic, NTFS, Healthy (Primary Partition)?

After being manually formatted, does it successully pass a command-line check for bad sectors: chkdsk driveletter: /r /v

e.g. if it's formatted as d:\ drive, then "chksk d: /r /v" from an administrator command prompt.